Presumed Innocent, released in theaters on July 27, 1990 and based on Scott Turow’s acclaimed novel, is a taut and intricate mystery that delves into the dark underbelly of the justice system when one of its own becomes the prime suspect. It’s a compelling and morally ambiguous film that keeps audiences guessing with its complex plot and powerful performances.
The story centers on Rusty Sabich (Harrison Ford), a respected and seemingly incorruptible chief deputy prosecutor in a bustling metropolitan district. His life takes a catastrophic turn when his colleague and former lover, Carolyn Polhemus (Greta Scacchi), is found brutally murdered. What begins as a routine investigation quickly spirals into a nightmare for Rusty when he becomes the lead suspect, largely due to his past affair with Carolyn.
Rusty finds himself caught in a devastating legal and personal battle. His boss, District Attorney Raymond Horgan (Brian Dennehy), initially stands by him, but as political pressures mount and damning evidence surfaces, Rusty is indicted for Carolyn’s murder. He hires the brilliant and enigmatic defense attorney Alejandro “Sandy” Stern (Raul Julia), who meticulously works to unravel the prosecution’s case.
As the trial unfolds, the film expertly navigates the complexities of legal procedure, political maneuvering, and the murky details of Carolyn’s life. Rusty’s loyal wife, Barbara Sabich (Bonnie Bedelia), struggles with the public humiliation and her husband’s past infidelity, yet stands by him.
The cast is further enriched by Paul Winfield as Judge Lyttle, John Spencer as Detective Lipranzer, and Joe Grifasi as Tommy Molto, the prosecuting attorney.
The narrative twists and turns, revealing layers of corruption, hidden motives, and shocking revelations that cast doubt on everyone involved.
The film was followed by a television miniseries, The Burden of Proof starring Hector Elizondo in 1992, and a television film sequel, Innocent starring Bill Pullman in 2011.
Apple TV+ produced an eight-part miniseries based on the film, starring Jake Gyllenhaal as Rusty Sabich. The miniseries debuted in June 2024.
Greta Scacchi and Brian Dennehy in Presumed Innocent (Photo/Warner Bros.)
Reception for Presumed Innocent
Presumed Innocent grossed $11.7 million on its opening weekend, finishing No. 1 at the box office, besting Ghost ($11.1 million) in its third weekend of release.
The film would gross $86.3 million during the epic summer of 1990’s blockbusters lineup and ended up as the eighth highest grossing film of the year.
Presumed Innocent would gross $221.3 million worldwide.
Roger Ebert gave the film three and a half stars in his review.
Lasting Legacy
Presumed Innocent is significant for its intelligent adaptation of a complex legal thriller and its unflinching portrayal of how easily a person’s life can be dismantled by suspicion and circumstance.
Ford delivers a nuanced performance as the beleaguered Rusty, conveying his quiet desperation and moral struggle. However, it is Julia’s commanding and charismatic portrayal of Sandy Stern that truly stands out, elevating the courtroom scenes.
The film is remembered for its intricate plot, its suspenseful atmosphere, and its thought-provoking exploration of truth, justice, and the inherent flaws within the legal system. It remains a benchmark for legal thrillers, proving that a compelling mystery, combined with strong character work, can be both intellectually stimulating and deeply engaging.
